Skip to content
CRR logo
Submit Search
Join E-mail List | Contact Us
  • Topics
  • Publications
  • Initiatives
  • Data
  • Sponsors
  • Opportunities
  • About Us
  • Search

401(k) Balances Increased Very Little in the Last 10 Years 

August 8, 2016
Share
Mobile Share Email Facebook Bluesky Twitter LinkedIn

MarketWatch Blog by Alicia H. Munnell

Headshot of Alicia H. Munnell

Alicia H. Munnell is a columnist for MarketWatch and senior advisor of the Center for Retirement Research at Boston College.

Auto enrollment without auto escalation of default contribution rate is part of the problem.    

Every year, Vanguard puts out a comprehensive report “How America Saves” that summarizes the statistics for the defined contribution plans that the company administers.  Vanguard tends to administer larger plans, so the plans are better designed than average and participants have higher incomes.  In other words, it presents the best face of the 401(k) system.  

My focus here is account balances.  In 2015, the average account balance was $96,300; the median was $26,400.  Between 2014 and 2015, the average account balance was down 6 percent and the median down 11 percent.  

This decline was attributable to three factors.  The first is the rising adoption of auto-enrollment, which increases participation but also produces smaller balances.  That is, more people save, but – because employees are typically enrolled at a default contribution rate of 3 percent – the accumulations are small.  Second, markets were essentially flat in 2015, with the average one-year participant return equal to -0.4 percent.  Third, Vanguard’s business mix was changing in that new firms moving over to Vanguard had lower account balances.  

While Vanguard’s explanation for the decline in average and median balances between 2014 and 2015 alleviates concerns about the short-run performance of the 401(k) system, a longer-run perspective raises troubling questions.  Figure 1 shows average and median balances for the last ten years in 2015 dollars.  In terms of medians, 2015 is actually lower than 2006.  This pattern could well reflect the expansion of auto-enrollment where a 3-percent default rate creates many small accounts.  The fact that the average account balance in 2015 was only $7,200 higher than that in 2006 is more of a concern, since a relatively small number of large accounts affects this number.  However, this pattern could be explained by the age distribution of the participants since the percentage of young participants, who have small balances, has increased over time.

Bar graph showing Vanguard Account Balances in Thousands of 2015 Dollars, 2006-2015

To get away from the impact of more young participants, it’s useful to look at balances for those ages 55-64, a group approaching retirement.  As one would expect, these balances are roughly twice as large as those for the participant population as a whole (see Figure 2).  But the pattern is quite similar; 2015 balances are only slightly higher than those in 2006.

Bar graph showing Account Balances for Vanguard Participants Ages 55-64 in Thousands of 2015 Dollars, 2006-2015

The data on balances suggest that we have not made a lot of progress in terms of 401(k) saving.  And Vanguard balances are probably higher than average given that it administers a large number of big plans.  On the other hand, many people approaching retirement have moved some 401(k) balances over to Individual Retirement Accounts (IRAs).  In 2013, the date of the latest Federal Reserve Survey of Consumer Finances, the median 401(k)/IRA holdings of working individuals with a 401(k) approaching retirement (55-64) were $100,000.  So the picture is somewhat less bleak than the Vanguard data alone would suggest.  But bleak, nevertheless.  

The one immediate policy implication suggested by these numbers is that auto-enrollment without auto-escalation may well do more harm than good.  If people are auto-enrolled at a 3-percent contribution rate, they are likely to stay with that rate.  They may be worse off than if they were allowed to enroll at a later date on their own with an average contribution rate.  My preference is to make auto-enrollment and auto-escalation mandatory for all 401(k) plans, starting at a default contribution rate of 6 percent and rising gradually to 10 percent.  

Clearly changes are needed if 401(k) plans are going to be an effective savings mechanism.  

Rows of piggy banks of all equal size
Rows of piggy banks of all equal size
Downloads
PDF Version
Related Content

Read on MarketWatch

Topics
Financing Retirement
Publication Type
MarketWatch Blog
Related Articles
Retirement with 401k plan route on a USA highway road sign with a stormy sky

A Strong Year for 401(k) Balances Masks the Truth About Long-Term Performance

MarketWatch Blog by Alicia H. Munnell

July 30, 2024
Illustrations of working women

Women’s Progress on Retirement Saving – Within Limits

Squared Away Blog by Kimberly Blanton

December 19, 2023
Miniature people_Elderly people sitting on different sized coins stacks

Low Earners Need More Retirement Income

MarketWatch Blog by Alicia H. Munnell

November 6, 2023

Support timely research that informs real-world solutions.

About us
Contact
Join e-mail list
Facebook Bluesky Twitter LinkedIn Instagram YouTube RSS

© 2025 Trustees of Boston College, Center for Retirement Research|Terms of Use|Privacy Policy|Accessibility

This website uses cookies to improve your experience. We also use IP addresses, domain information and other access statistics to administer the site and analyze usage trends. If you prefer to opt out, you can select Update settings. Read our Privacy Policy. Accept
Privacy & Cookies Policy

Privacy Overview

This website uses cookies to improve your experience while you navigate through the website. Out of these cookies, the cookies that are categorized as necessary are stored on your browser as they are essential for the working of basic functionalities of the website. We also use third-party cookies that help us analyze and understand how you use this website. These cookies will be stored in your browser only with your consent. You also have the option to opt-out of these cookies. But opting out of some of these cookies may have an effect on your browsing experience.
Necessary
Always Enabled
Necessary cookies are absolutely essential for the website to function properly. This category only includes cookies that ensures basic functionalities and security features of the website. These cookies do not store any personal information.
Non-necessary
Any cookies that may not be particularly necessary for the website to function and is used specifically to collect user personal data via analytics, ads, other embedded contents are termed as non-necessary cookies. It is mandatory to procure user consent prior to running these cookies on your website.
SAVE & ACCEPT